How to Choose a High Force Push Pull Solenoid
The mechanical requirements should be the starting point in the selection of a high force push pull solenoid and not the available product catalog.
1. Find the force you need
Find out the minimum force at the actual position. The force of the solenoid reduces when the plunger is displaced from the magnetic pole. Thus, the statement “100 N force” is not sufficient without the stroke.
2. Explain the stroke.
Specify the actual stroke, e.g., 3 mm, 5 mm, 10 mm, or 20 mm. Don’t choose a very long stroke solenoid just because the maximum stroke looks very attractive.
3. Adjust the working voltage.
The DC12V, DC24V, and other DC voltages are the common needs in industry. The coil needs to be optimized for the particular power supply and control electronics.
4. Duty cycle check
Does the solenoid work continuously, intermittently, or with short pulses? If a coil works continuously, it will overheat if it is designed for intermittent operation.
5. Consider the operating frequency.
A machine, which works multiple times per minute, requires a different solenoid than a machine, which works hundreds or thousands of times per hour. Frequency of cycles determines the heat accumulation, wear, spring fatigue, and service life.
6. Measure installation dimensions.
Check the full dimensions, mounting holes, shaft diameter, shaft length, connector location, and space for the movement.
7. Check load direction.
Determine if the application needs pulling, pushing, or both. The actual loading of the solenoid may vary greatly using the mechanical linkage.
8. Consider the environmental conditions.
The final design should be determined only after evaluation of the requirements for temperature, humidity, dust, oil, vibrations, water, and corrosion.
9. Prototype testing
Test the solenoid before mass production under the real voltage, load, stroke, duty cycle, temperature, and mechanical installation conditions.
For OEM projects, such parameters are provided to the manufacturer for the selection/development of a high-force push-pull solenoid for the particular application.
Common Pitfalls to Avoid When Designing High Force Push Pull Solenoid
The performance problems are usually caused by the number of design mistakes.
Error 1: Push without a stroke
Always indicate the force needed at a certain stroke.
Error 2: Considering the maximum force as the operating force.
The maximum force is close to the start position. The working force can be much lower.
Mistake #3: Forgetting about the duty cycle.
The high-force coil produces a lot of heat. You need to find out the expected time of energization and cycle frequency.
Error 4: Choosing voltage first and then force.
“The voltage is important, but it’s the magnetic circuit, coil resistance, stroke, and available power all working together.”
Mistake 5: Not considering the return force requirements.
If a spring is used, its force should be considered in mechanical calculations.
Mistake 6. Not providing sufficient installation tolerance.
Shaft alignment, mounting tolerances, and surroundings should be considered.”
Mistake 7: Testing without the actual load.
The solenoid, which works when it is not loaded, may not work when installed in the machine.
Error 8: Forgetting about the temperature.
Coil resistance and performance depend on the temperature. Thermal testing is a part of prototype validation.
Mistake 9: Choosing the wrong size solenoid when you don’t have to.
An oversize actuator will add power, cost, size, and heat without improving the machine performance.














