How to Pick a Robotic Holding Magnet
Choosing a proper robotic holding magnet requires more than just comparison of the advertised holding force. The magnet must match the workpiece, robot, end effector, operating environment and automation cycle.
1. Find out the material of the workpiece.
Make sure that the workpiece is highly ferromagnetic. Mild steels usually have better magnetic attraction than stainless steels and other types of materials with poor magnetic response.
2. Measure the thickness of the workpiece.
Small workpiece thickness may reduce drastically the holding force of the magnet. Instead of selecting the magnet for the heaviest workpiece, it is necessary to identify the minimum and maximum thickness of the material that the robot processes.
3. Analyze the surface condition.
Paint, rust, scale, oil, dirt, rough surface, air gaps reduce significantly the effective holding force. A magnet that works well with clean steel may perform badly with coated or rough material.
4. Determine the dynamic load.
Consider not only the weight of the workpiece, but also robot acceleration, deceleration, vibrations, robot orientation and centrifugal effects. The dynamic forces are higher than the static load.
5. Select the factor of safety.
Never use the magnet in the proximity of its maximum theoretical holding capacity. Use a safety margin based on engineering assessment of the application and consequences of the dropped load.
6. Robot payload compatibility.
Robot should not only handle the workpiece, but also the magnet, mounting hardware and sensors, the cables and other equipment. A very powerful but heavy magnet may reduce the robot payload capacity.
7. Choose a magnetic technology.
Permanent magnets do not need any electrical power to keep the workpiece held. Electromagnets allow controlling activation, but consume electricity. Electro-permanent magnets are an intermediate solution.
8. Consider the speed of operation.
For high speed applications, activation and release times are very important. Select a magnet able to perform the pick and release cycle.
9. Analyze the mounting and control.
Select the mounting and flange dimensions, consider mounting orientation, voltage, control interface, sensor compatibility and cable routing.
10. Test the magnet on the real workpiece.
Perform tests with the actual material, workpiece thickness, workpiece surface condition, robot speed and robot orientation. Testing in practice is one of the best methods of verifying reliable operation.
Tips for Avoiding Common Mistakes in Robotic Holding Magnet Design
Don’t select the magnet by the weight of the workpiece.
When calculating loads, take into consideration the robot acceleration and deceleration.
Don’t confuse the maximum advertised holding force with the actual holding force.
Check the exact steel grade before choosing magnetic technology.
Includes paint, oil, rust, scale and surface voids.
Check the minimum workpiece thickness.
Don’t oversized magnets and increase the robot payload unnecessarily.
Don’t forget to provide appropriate safety factor for dynamic operation.
Don’t forget to check if the magnet still performs at the desired temperature.
Position magnetic poles for the maximum useful contact area.
Consider the center of gravity when lifting the workpiece.
Route cables away from robot movements.
Don’t forget to check the switching voltage and control requirements of the magnet.
Install workpiece detection or magnetic status feedback if required.
Perform complete test of the robot-magnet-workpiece system prior to production.
Check the behavior of emergency stop and loss of power.
Don’t release a load until the robot is in a safe position and destination.
Consider workpiece wear, contamination and maintenance requirements.
Ensure that mounting hardware can withstand repeated dynamic loads.
Document the inspection procedure. Document the final operational limits.














